SaaS accounting software Vs SaaS accounting expert

October 27, 2024

By Neethu

In today’s fast-paced, tech-driven business landscape, one of the most important functions of any company is accounting. Whether it’s a start-up, a small business, or an established corporation, accurate financial information that’s available in a reliable format is critical for growth.

Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) accounting software offers affordable, user-friendly solutions that promise to simplify and automate financial management. On the other hand, there’s the time-tested approach of hiring an accounting expert, someone with industry knowledge and experience to handle your business finances.

It’s not always a one or the other type of decision, rather it’s more about how to optimally use software and automation and an expert who’s been there and done that.

Is SaaS accounting software the solution?

Here is a fun little story just to illustrate a point. Mind you, this is pure fiction…but perhaps some parts are familiar to you!

Once upon a time, in a bustling SaaS start-up, there was a CEO named Dave. Dave was an incredible visionary. He knew the future of tech, could map out complex user journeys, and had a killer instinct for product-market fit. But when it came to accounting? Well, Dave believed, “How hard could it be?”

After all, SaaS accounting seemed simple enough, right? You’ve got subscriptions, some renewals, a few upgrades, and the occasional “I forgot my password” support ticket. Easy-peasy! So, Dave decided the company didn’t need to hire an accountant—they could handle it in-house. Big mistake.

One day, Dave noticed something odd. A customer had sent in a support ticket saying, “Hey, I love your product, but why did you just invoice me for 50,000 seats? I only have five employees!”

Confused, Dave checked the invoice. Absolute shock! Turns out, in an attempt to set up an “automated” billing system, Dave had linked subscription costs to the number of mouse clicks made in the product dashboard, oops! The more the customer clicked, the more they were charged.

Needless to say, the support team was flooded with angry emails from customers who were being billed for every impatient click while waiting for a page to load Realizing the scope of the disaster, Dave panicked. He tried to correct the error by issuing refunds. But instead of returning the overcharges, he accidentally refunded the company’s entire yearly revenue to one particularly active customer.

To make matters worse, Dave had forgotten to track any of these financial mishaps correctly. When tax season arrived, the company’s books were in complete disarray—subscriptions looked like random decimals, expenses were filed under “Miscellaneous Chaos,” and revenue was either inflated or mysteriously evaporated. The final blow came when the company’s accountant—hastily hired at the last minute—took one look at the numbers, and fainted!

From that day on, Dave learned two important lessons: first, SaaS accounting is far more complex than it seems, and second, always leave it to the experts unless you want to start charging customers based on how many times they refresh the dashboard.

SaaS accounting software Vs SaaS accounting expert

So, which is the better option—using SaaS accounting software, or investing in the expertise of a professional accountant or as in most cases, a hybrid? Let’s look at the strengths and weaknesses of each option, examine common pitfalls and dangers associated with self-serve accounting, and make a case for the value that an industry-savvy accounting expert can bring to your business. We’ll explore:

Understanding SaaS Accounting Software
The Role of a SaaS Accounting Expert
The Benefits of SaaS Accounting Software
The Pitfalls and Dangers of Self-Serve Accounting
The Value of an Industry-Specific Accounting Expert
Which Option is Better for Your Business?
Making an Informed Decision

1. Understanding SaaS Accounting Software

SaaS accounting software is cloud-based financial management software that helps businesses track their expenses, manage payroll, prepare invoices, and generate financial reports in the simplest terms. The software is delivered online through a subscription model, typically with various tiers of service depending on the size and needs of your business; well that should be easily understand given the businesses’ own SaaS model.

Popular SaaS accounting software include QuickBooks Online, Xero, Zohobooks, and Wave accounting, among others. These tools are often advertised as user-friendly, with built-in automation for tasks like expense categorisation, invoicing, and sometimes tax filing. They can also integrate with third-party applications, providing a more streamlined workflow for business owners.

While these platforms can handle a wide range of accounting tasks, it’s important to note that they are often designed with general accounting principles in mind, rather than specialised knowledge of your industry.

2. The Role of a SaaS Accounting Professional

A SaaS accounting professional brings something that software alone cannot provide: human expertise and experience of different business and revenue models. These professionals are usually certified accountants or bookkeepers who are not only proficient with SaaS tools but also possess in-depth knowledge of specific accounting processes, tax laws, and regulatory compliance.

Unlike the generalised approach of accounting software, an expert can offer tailored advice that align with your business’s specific financial challenges. They can help you with:

Industry-specific regulations: Every industry has its own accounting quirks. For instance, SaaS is notorious for revenue recognition principles which is often cumbersome and needs specific attention
Strategic financial planning: Experts help businesses not just manage their finances, but plan for growth, optimise taxes, and stay compliant with industry-specific regulations.
Problem-solving and advice: A SaaS accounting expert can diagnose issues in your financial health that software might not flag, offering in person solutions and guidance. What you cannot do with software is have a real 1-1 which can be absolutely critical when it comes to talking matters out for the SaaS company founder.

3. The Benefits of SaaS Accounting Software

Affordability: One of the main draws of SaaS accounting software is its relatively low cost compared to hiring a full-time or even a part-time accounting expert. Subscriptions range from as little as $10 to $50 a month for basic plans, making them a budget-friendly option for small businesses and start-ups.

Automation and Efficiency: SaaS accounting software is designed to automate repetitive tasks, which can save business owners valuable time. Features like bank feeds, payable automation and payroll processing allow business owners to handle their financial tasks fast without requiring in-depth accounting knowledge.

Accessibility: Because SaaS accounting software is cloud-based, it can be accessed from anywhere, allowing business owners and managers to check their financial status in real time. This is particularly beneficial for businesses with remote teams or multiple locations.

Integration: Most SaaS platforms offer integration with other business applications like CRM systems, payment processors, and project management tools. This allows for a seamless flow of data across different departments, enhancing overall productivity.

Financial Tracking: With dashboards and reports nearly in real-time, SaaS accounting software offers instant insight into your business’s financial status. This immediate feedback can be valuable for making quick, data-driven decisions.

4. The Pitfalls and Dangers of Self-Serve Accounting

Despite its many advantages, self-serve accounting with SaaS software carries several risks. Small business owners who handle their accounting may be unaware of common pitfalls that can lead to financial problems, compliance issues, or missed opportunities for tax savings.

Lack of Expertise: SaaS accounting software is built to be user-friendly, but it cannot replace the knowledge and expertise of a trained accountant. For example, while the software can automatically categorize expenses, it might not do so in a way that maximizes your tax deductions. Similarly, without a solid understanding of accounting principles, a business owner may misinterpret financial reports, leading to poor decision-making.

Overconfidence in Automation: Automation is a great feature, but it also presents risks. Business owners may become over-reliant on the software, assuming that everything is being done correctly. However, automated systems are only as good as the rules they follow. Incorrect setup or failing to review automated entries can lead to costly errors.

Compliance Risks: Tax laws and industry regulations are complex and constantly evolving. SaaS software is updated regularly to reflect these changes, but without an understanding of specific regulations, business owners may overlook important compliance issues. Mistakes in tax filings or missed deadlines can lead to fines, audits, or even legal action.

Limited Customisation: While most SaaS accounting platforms offer a range of features, they are often designed with a one-size-fits-all approach. Customizing reports, workflows, or invoicing may be difficult or require expensive add-ons. This can be limiting for businesses with specific or complex needs.

Time Investment: Although SaaS software saves time by automating certain tasks, managing your own accounting can still be time-consuming. Small business owners may find themselves spending too much time on their finances instead of focusing on core business activities, which could hinder growth.

5. The Value of an Industry-Specific Accounting Expert

While software can handle basic accounting tasks, the complexities of business finances, especially in niche industries, require a deeper level of understanding. Hiring an industry-specific accounting expert can offer a range of benefits that a SaaS platform simply cannot provide.

Tailored Financial Strategies: An expert accountant doesn’t just categorize expenses or generate reports—they help businesses develop long-term financial strategies. This can include everything from maximizing tax deductions, to planning for capital investments, to optimizing cash flow. Their knowledge of your industry’s financial challenges ensures that the strategies they recommend are relevant and effective.

Tax Optimization: A SaaS platform can calculate taxes, but it can’t optimize them. Industry-specific accountants understand the nuances of tax law and can help businesses reduce their tax liabilities through strategies such as deferred taxes, credits, and deductions specific to their field. For example, a SaaS accountant familiar with tech startups might know how to leverage R&D tax credits, whereas an accounting platform would simply tally up taxable income.

Human Insight and Problem Solving: Accounting software lacks the ability to offer personalized advice or diagnose problems beyond generic error messages. An accountant can spot red flags in your financial statements, suggest ways to increase profitability, or warn you of future cash flow problems. This kind of insight is invaluable for businesses aiming to stay competitive in their market.

Industry Compliance Expertise: Each industry has its own set of regulations and accounting standards. For example, healthcare providers must comply with HIPAA and industry-specific insurance requirements, while nonprofit organizations face unique reporting standards. A SaaS accountant with expertise in your industry ensures that your business remains compliant with these specific regulations, reducing the risk of fines or audits.

Long-Term Partnership: Hiring an expert accountant can also establish a long-term partnership. As your business grows, the accountant becomes familiar with your financial history and can offer deeper insights and more strategic advice. This relationship fosters trust and allows for more tailored, forward-thinking planning.

6. Which Option is Better for Your Business?

Deciding between SaaS accounting software and hiring a SaaS accounting expert ultimately depends on several factors:

Business Size: For very small businesses or startups with limited budgets, SaaS accounting software may be sufficient, especially for handling basic tasks like invoicing and expense tracking. However, as the business grows and its financial complexities increase, the need for an expert accountant becomes more pressing.

Industry-Specific Needs: Industries with complex financial regulations or tax requirements will benefit from the expertise of an accountant familiar with the industry. Businesses in construction, healthcare, tech startups, and e-commerce, for example, face financial challenges that general-purpose accounting software may not fully address.

Budget: Cost is always a factor, but it’s essential to consider the potential savings and benefits that come with hiring an accountant. While SaaS accounting software offers a lower upfront cost, the long-term value of tax optimization, compliance assurance, and strategic financial advice often outweighs the savings.

Time and Resources: Running a business requires focus. If managing finances takes too much time away from other essential tasks, it may be more cost-effective to hire an accountant who can handle those responsibilities efficiently and accurately.

Whatever you do, make sure it’s an informed decision

SaaS accounting software and SaaS accounting experts each have their advantages and disadvantages. For small businesses with basic accounting needs, SaaS software provides an affordable and efficient solution. However, for businesses facing complex financial challenges or those operating in regulated industries, the expertise of an accountant is invaluable.

Ultimately, the decision comes down to the size and complexity of your business, as well as the time and resources you can devote to financial management. While accounting software is a great tool, it cannot replace the personalized insight, strategic planning, and industry-specific knowledge that a seasoned accountant can provide.

Remember to carefully evaluate your needs and understand the limitations of self-serve accounting. Doing so will help you make the right choice for your business—whether it’s relying on technology, human expertise, or a combination of both.

Share the Post: